Mar 052014
Better Than New

Better Than New

I’ve enjoyed my 1999 BMW E36 M3 for more than 10 years. When the car was introduced back in 1995, it sparked criticism from some BMW enthusiasts. The E36 M3 wasn’t as raw as its E30 predecessor, a truly iconic car. The version sold in North America also did not have the more exotic and powerful engines of the European model. So despite accolades like Car and Driver naming it the best handling car in America in 1997, the E36 in many ways has been the least appreciated of the BMW M3 generations.

The passage of time seems to be changing this view. As BMWs have gotten bigger, heavier, more software dependent and less reliable, older generations have begun to  be more and more appreciated by a core group of BMW enthusiasts. The latest catalyst for this reappraisal has been the great amount of press greeting the introduction of the 2014 BMW M235i.

In three separate reviews, this car is touted as the one that returns BMW to its dynamic driving roots and could entice old school enthusiasts to give up their older models. In two of the reviews, the E36 M3 is specifically called out as an example of what BMW used to represent.

The review  by Jeff Sabatini in the April Car and Driver describes this particular kind of BMW enthusiast really well:

“You know them by the tarnish on their roundels, the newest of which are now eight model years old and at least two generation obsolete. BMW knows them for their unwillingness to replace their beloved E36 and E46 Bimmers with the larger, and in management’s view, much-improved successors. This uniquely American cohort perplexes the Germans because such refusal comes despite, or perhaps because of, a self-avowed passion for the brand. The 2014 2-Series is Munich’s latest and best attempt to bring this crowd back into the fold.”

At Automobile magazine Michael Jordan amplifies this point and connects it right to the E36 M3 – sorry, no link up yet:

“Second, it (the M235i) makes you think you’ve taken a ride in the BMW wayback machine, since this car combines the intensely personal feeling of the 1970s 2002tii with the affordability and drivability of the legendary, late 1990s E36 chassis M3.”

Legendary – what a difference 15 years can make! Rich Farquhar at Bimmer magazine also gives the M235i a positive review but in some ways prefer the 228i because its very comparable to the (you guessed it) E36 M3:

“As much as we enjoyed the M235i, we can’t help but be intrigued by its little brother. Its 240 hp and 6.2-second 0-60 time put it more or less on par with the old E36 M3, and so does its $33,025 base price, $9,000 less than the MSRP on an M235i.”

Why BMW has lost the hearts of enthusiasts is a topic for another post. To continue to grow and be profitable there are strong market forces the company needs to respond to. However I’m on record that some of BMW’s decisions make it very hard for a certain kind of BMW enthusiastic. The cracks are starting to widen between the premium image and the driving reality of newer models.

Until that fact begins to cut into sales, this debate will take place mainly in car magazines, online forums and sites like this one. In the meantime, it’s a lot of fun to see a superlative driver like my E36 M3 get its due. I’ll just keep driving like it’s 1999.


  3 Responses to “The E36 M3 — More Appreciated Every Year”

  1. Agreed. Nothing can beat the e36m3. For overall driving pleasure and quality. I was hoping the 2 series would be my next move, but its still too heavy to be a replacement. And likely unreliable.

  2. I agree with several of the comments, unfortunately in the end
    its all about volume and bringing the almighty buck to the bottom line.
    Unfortunately there are not enough so called enthusiasts to make this happen.

    Plus government regulations regarding fuel efficiency has forced manufactures to bolt on turbo technology.

    There are however current BMW’s that will still appeal to the BMW purist.

    The 2008 BMW 128, 2006 BMW 330, 2008 BMW 328’s, 2011 1M, with more on the horizon.

    As models do evolve and seem to be growing larger they are at the same time getting more powerful and getting better gas mileage. There also seems to be smaller models being introduced in each model segment. They are still all very close to 50/50 weight distribution and BMW is staying true to their inherent desire to continually focus on efficient dynamics.

    I do agree that the older models have aged beautifully and the fact that they aren’t loaded with electronics make them sought after as the mechanics have become technicians and need some pretty sophisticated technology to plug in to the new models.

    15 years ago we would have never thought that BMW would be using turbo power, electric steering, xDrive with M product but we have I learned to never say never when commenting on BMW.

    Although there may be widening cracks regarding some models past hertitage we still have modern day models that I would challenge anyone will offer you the ultimate in driving handling and feel and will out handle and perform the previous generations. BMW is a car company with a driving passion to continually get better and offer more time and time again.

    By the way I just sold my 1998 328 Coupe and replace it with a 2000 BMW 323 Coupe.
    Every day driver is a BMW 335ix Sedan. One last note with the addition of all these turbo engines….boosting power (if you want or feel the need) has never been easier or more affordable and more importantly one area where BMW should improve in the Canadian market place is paying for the maintenance more often. 2013 and previous was once a year or every 24,000 kilometers. 2014 and moving forward is every 15000 kilometers and although getting better still not good enough with the turbo engines.

    Every 8000-10000 kilometers will pay off in the long run big time.

    Happy motoring BMW Drivers.

  3. Redouble both “More Appreciated” and Fraser’s particularly lucid analysis.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>