How consumers are tracked online has been an issue for years. Until recently the main vehicle for this tracking has been the cookie, a small file placed on a visitor’s browser that identifies repeat visits and online activity. The latest chapter of this debate to reach critical media mass concerns Internet Service Providers (ISPs) contracting with companies to place hardware inside their networks to track all user online activity. This tracking produces profiles that aim to target advertising of interest to users, better supporting the online advertising market and giving ISPs a slice of the revenue.
Saul Hansell of the New York Times wrote a good article recently that has attracted over 60, mostly angry comments:
Bobby White of The Journal had it back in December: http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB119690164549315192-9g6E0Km1JMR4eAm55Es_16QrvkU_20081205.html?mod=rss_free
The technology has progressed, yet these are the same exact issues I dealt with when I was VP of Corporate Communications at Advertising.com. It was the beginning of the pay-per-click (PPC) era, and cookies were a new and scary concept. People were upset that their travels could be seen across the Internet — recall the famous New Yorker ad with the caption “On the Internet, no one knows you’re a dog!” Well, that level of anonymity was never accurate, and it’s getting less so every day.
Back then (circa 1999-2000) we were active with industry groups like the Network Advertising Initiative and the Online Privacy Alliance and worked hard to educate consumers regarding exactly what was happening when they were online. We (and hearings at the FTC) helped put in place a set of principles that tried to balance the needs of advertisers and the rights of online users. Basically they’ve been in place since then and encompass:
2. Notice and Disclosure
4. Data Security
5. Data Quality and Access
Most of the media coverage on this includes claims there will be some kind of consent given, but how clearly will it be spelled out? Supposedly there will be safeguards so the data can never be personally identified with me — but what exactly are they, and how will they be enforced? Surely there will be an economic incentive to include more and more personally identifiable information to justify higher advertising rates.
And what’s the benefit to me as a user — more and more advertising, albeit the “right” advertising based on my interests? How compelling to the average consumer does the advertising industry really think that is? There isn’t enough transparency about exactly what is going on. If companies are not very clear about what’s happening, there is a huge risk for a big public backlash and resulting clumsy government regulation.
There’s a very old and established way that a free market economy assigns value to something, and I’m surprised none of the coverage I’ve seen mentions it. It’s pretty simple — PAY PEOPLE for agreeing to allow their online activity to be tracked. I pay good money every month for my broadband access, too much in fact if you compare it to what people pay in other countries.
You want my data — then take $10 off my monthly bill, or guarantee me my rate won’t go up as long as I participate. Be very clear about what’s going on — for example, as clear as my monthly bill is — and cut users in on the action. That bargain IMHO will be accepted by a good percentage of consumers, and represents a big first mover advantage (market AND PR) to whatever major ISP jumps in first.
7/1 UPDATE — ISPs are backing away, better offer that cut to end customers fast:
One week after Charter Communications voiced concerns about controversial behavioral targeting company NebuAd, two other Internet service providers appear to be distancing themselves from the company.
Other stories you might like:
- Why Online Advertising Must Change I don’t work in online advertising any longer. But I was present at the creation...
- The Supercookie Debate Have you heard about the supercookie? Recent articles in the press have outlined how sites...
- Your Personal Data as Online Currency Online privacy and how consumer data is tracked online has been a recurring theme on...